Federal Appeals Court Upholds U.S. TikTok Ban, Setting Stage for Supreme Court Fight

by | Dec 6, 2024

A federal appeals court has upheld a law that would effectively ban TikTok in the United States, delivering a significant blow to the popular video-sharing app as the federal government intensifies efforts to address national security concerns tied to its Chinese ownership.

 

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled against TikTok and its parent company, ByteDance, in a unanimous decision by a three-judge panel. The court declined to review the companies’ petition challenging the law.

“We conclude the portions of the Act the petitioners have standing to challenge, that is the provisions concerning TikTok and its related entities, survive constitutional scrutiny,” wrote Senior Judge Douglas Ginsburg in the majority opinion. He emphasized the government’s goal of protecting Americans from potential foreign influence. “The First Amendment exists to protect free speech in the United States. Here the Government acted solely to protect that freedom from a foreign adversary nation.”

The decision clears the way for the law, which takes effect on January 19, unless TikTok succeeds in its likely appeal to the Supreme Court. Both parties have urged the high court to act swiftly, with a request for a decision by Friday to allow time for review. The Supreme Court could either pause the law or let the appeals court ruling stand as the final word.

The law, passed as part of a foreign assistance package in April and signed by Joe Biden, requires TikTok to sever ties with ByteDance or face removal from U.S. app stores and web-hosting services. Lawmakers and national security officials have long warned that TikTok’s Chinese ownership poses a risk, citing the potential for the Chinese government to exploit the platform for espionage or influence operations.

TikTok has over 170 million U.S. users, and critics argue that Chinese national security laws could compel ByteDance to share user data with Beijing. The court acknowledged the law’s far-reaching impact on TikTok’s users, noting they would need to find alternative platforms.

“That burden is attributable to the [People’s Republic of China’s] hybrid commercial threat to U.S. national security, not to the U.S. Government,” Ginsburg wrote.

TikTok and ByteDance have argued that the law violates the First Amendment and imposes an “unprecedented and unconstitutional” restriction on speech. In their legal challenge, they described the legislation as based on speculative fears and claimed that a forced sale of TikTok would be technologically and commercially unfeasible.

China has also vowed to block the sale of TikTok’s proprietary algorithm, which powers the app’s content recommendations. TikTok’s lawyers argue that rebuilding the algorithm would be impossible under the restrictions outlined in the law.

Justice Department attorney Daniel Tenny defended the law, highlighting the risks of data collection and content manipulation by China. “The data collected could be quite valuable to a foreign adversary if it were trying to approach an American to serve as an intelligence asset,” Tenny said.

The ruling underscores a growing tension between protecting national security and upholding free speech rights. While TikTok’s legal team argues the law suppresses speech based on speculative risks, the government maintains that the platform’s foreign ties pose a clear and present danger.

 

CBS News

 

 

Top News

Trump’s Top Cybersecurity Official Announces Departure

Trump’s Top Cybersecurity Official Announces Departure

White House National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross is leaving the Trump administration, giving the White House time to secure Senate confirmation for his replacement before Democrats take control of Congress in January.   His departure was described by sources...

U.S. and Venezuela Agree to Strengthen Military Cooperation

U.S. and Venezuela Agree to Strengthen Military Cooperation

The United States and Venezuela have agreed to restore and expand military cooperation following an unexpected visit by War Secretary Pete Hegseth to Caracas on Wednesday, where he met with interim President Delcy Rodríguez.   The agreement was signed with...

Highly Classified NSA Communications Network Goes Dark

Highly Classified NSA Communications Network Goes Dark

A highly classified communications network used by the National Security Agency (NSA) for internal communications went down Tuesday, according to CNN, citing five people familiar with the situation.   The network, known as NSA Net, allows agency employees to...